centerlogobigAAD logo

enarzh-CNnlfrdehiplrues
American

Preet Bharara, United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, and Diego Rodriguez, the Assistant Director-in-Charge of the New York Field Office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”), announced the arrest of ERIC IAN HORNAK SPOUTZ, a/k/a “Robert Chad Smith,” a/k/a “John Goodman,” a/k/a “James Sinclair,” on charges of wire fraud in connection with the sale of dozens of forged artworks by renowned American artists, such as Willem De Kooning, Franz Kline, and Joan Mitchell. SPOUTZ was arrested in Los Angeles yesterday.

Manhattan U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara said: “As alleged, Eric Spoutz used false and fictitious provenance to peddle his forged artwork to unsuspecting buyers, claiming they were masterpieces from Willem De Kooning, Franz Kline and Joan Mitchell. Our Office has a long history of investigating – and prosecuting – those who try to contaminate the art world with fraudulent artwork. Thanks to the outstanding investigative work by the FBI, Spoutz’s alleged forgery mill is no longer in business.”

FBI Assistant Director-in-Charge Diego Rodriguez said: “As alleged, Eric Spoutz created an entire world of fiction to make a profit—from the fraudulent paintings he was selling, to the phony letters and receipts for provenance. The only real thing in this situation seems to be the financial losses the victims have incurred for purchasing what they thought were true works of art, whether for investment purposes or personal enjoyment.”

Screen Shot 2016 02 04 at 15.28.07Eric Ian Hornak Spoutz Lecturing Washington County Museum of Fine Arts 2013 - Image Credit - Natasha M. Spoutz

According to the allegations contained in the Complaint and other documents in the public record, and statements made in court:

Screen Shot 2016 02 04 at 15.35.27 copyEric Ian Spoutz and his wife, Natasha, then his fiancée, at their home in Harrison Township, Michigan, in 2012. Tom Watts / Macomb Daily — fileBetween 2010 and March 2015, SPOUTZ repeatedly sold works of art he falsely claimed were by well-known artists, using forged documents to convince buyers of the authenticity of those works. During the course of the scheme, SPOUTZ sold dozens of fraudulent works of art – which he attributed to, among others, Willem De Kooning, Franz Kline, and Joan Mitchell – through various channels, including auction houses and on EBay.

SPOUTZ was publicly accused of selling forged works of art as early as 2005, after which he began selling them under various aliases, particularly “Robert Chad Smith” and “John Goodman.” To deceive his victims into believing the works of art were authentic, SPOUTZ created and provided forged receipts, bills of sale, and letters from deceased attorneys and other individuals. These documents falsely indicated that SPOUTZ, in the guise of one of his false identities, had inherited or purchased dozens of works by these artists. 

Despite his efforts to create false histories for the artwork, investigators identified multiple inconsistencies and errors in SPOUTZ’s forged provenance documents. Many of the purported transactions took place before SPOUTZ was born, and the forged letters included non-existent addresses both for the purported sender and various parties referenced as sources of the artworks. SPOUTZ also consistently used a single distinctive typesetting when forging documents purportedly authored by entirely different art galleries in different decades regarding unrelated transactions. In one instance, investigators located the original letter used by SPOUTZ as a model for one of his forgeries in a collection at a private university, which holds a collection of letters from the individual whose identity SPOUTZ used to create a false story of inheritance.

SPOUTZ, 32, of Mount Clemens, Michigan, is charged with one count of wire fraud, which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison. The maximum potential sentence in this case is prescribed by Congress and is provided here for informational purposes only, as any sentencing of the defendant will be determined by a judge.

Unknown victims may have purchased artwork from SPOUTZ unwittingly under provenance documents using historical names such as “Betty Parsons Gallery,” “Larry Larkin,” “Henry Hecht,” and “Julius or Jay Wolf.”

The case is being prosecuted by the Office’s Money Laundering and Asset Forfeiture Unit. Assistant United States Attorney Andrew C. Adams is in charge of the prosecution. The charges contained in the Complaint are merely accusations, and the defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

Speaking with Alex Boyle AAD's Arts Editor about this prosecution, he was reminded of encounters many years ago with Mr. Spoutz. "I knew this guy" he said. "He always wanted me to lend him stuff, for some reason I didn't get the right feeling so I walked. Probably seemed rude, but in retrospect rather savant."

Most professional Art dealers have an innate and inbuilt ability to feel or smell a rat a mile away and for once that's shown up here at the right time.

NBC News pointed to a comment on a book titled Fake: Forgery, Lies, & eBay written by Kenneth Walton (for sale on Amazon), in which Eric I. Spoutz said of the book, "Walton's book is an easy read and, at times, quite humorous. However, the autobiographical tale of his criminal and fraudulent acts of selling fake art on-line is hampered by the young author's incessant blaming of eBay for "allowing" him to commit such crimes. Walton's tone is that of the preppy-murderer Robert Chambers who never seems to take responsibility for his crimes and actually blames the victims for allowing the crimes to be commmitted. In Walton's case, the victims are the buyers of his fraudulent art, eBay and the art community at-large. For fans of sociopathic, self-indulgent, unapologetic humor, this book is for you. You can also visit Walton's self-promo site to see him with friends eating cake and celebrating his crimes against the innocent. For all others, save yourself the time and read some art books instead."

Download the US v Spoutz complaint here.

www.justice.gov

About the Author

AAD REPORTS

AAD REPORTS

AAD REPORTS   Reports, news and opinion from Art-Antiques-Design.com